Thought Police

(Source: Page 8, The Indian Express)

Topic:GS2: Governance – Role of the Police, Fundamental Rights GS4: Ethics – Freedom of Expression, Integrity in Public Life

Context

A professor from Ashoka University, Ali Khan Mahmudabad, was arrested by Haryana Police for social media posts analyzing India’s Operation Sindoor. His arrest under charges like promoting enmity and endangering sovereignty raises serious concerns about misuse of laws and threats to academic freedom.

Background –

• Operation Sindoor was a military action launched by India following the Pahalgam terror attack in April 2025.

• The professor’s social media posts highlighted strategic dimensions and ethical concerns regarding war rhetoric.

• FIRs were filed based on complaints from political leaders, despite the posts being analytical and patriotic.

Misuse of Legal Provisions:

• Arrest was made under harsh sections, similar to sedition laws used in recent years to silence dissent.

• Legal instruments meant to safeguard national security are increasingly being weaponized against critique.

Threat to Academic Freedom:

• Institutes of higher education must remain spaces of critical inquiry and debate.

• The editorial points to a trend where critical reflections are criminalized, particularly in BJP-ruled states.

Ethics of Dissent and National Interest:

• Professor’s statements were balanced and highlighted India’s restraint and constitutional values.

• Arrest reflects shrinking space for ethical dissent, even when rooted in patriotism and strategic reasoning.

Judicial Intervention:

• The Supreme Court has agreed to hear the professor’s petition urgently.

• This reflects the importance of judicial safeguards in defending constitutional freedoms.

Conclusion/Way Forward

• There must be clear guidelines on applying national security laws to prevent misuse against critics.

• Academic and journalistic expression should be protected unless it incites violence or violates public order.

• Strengthening institutional checks on police actions and ensuring judicial oversight is key to preserving democracy.

• Promotion of constitutional morality and pluralism in public discourse is essential for national integrity.

---

Practice Question: Discuss the ethical and constitutional implications of using national security laws to curb dissent in academic and public spheres. Suggest safeguards to protect freedom of expression in a democracy. (250 words, 15 marks)